Sunday, January 10, 2021
Enforcers & Legitimatizers
The German Nazi party and Mussolini's facists benefitted greatly from a core group of enforcers that could be used to shift the overton window while providing cover for their public facing movements. It's a good technique. Religions often do this. It's all about 'layers'. Getting things to nest properly and in resonant ways is no easy task. It's why some scriptures are good and some are awful.
This summer we saw Democrats exploiting Antifa and BLM wonderfully. It filled their coffers unbelievably well, and that, I have no doubt, enabled a lot of ground game energy & shenanigans.
Right now we may start to see the Right follow suit. Trump has publicly denounced Capital violence. Is that just a cover-your behind move? Was he just really naive about a big show of numbers without expecting any real violence (other than ANTIFA counter violence)? Who knows. I'm not much into conspiracy. But, what is certain, is that groups which have a violent fringe movement, are an adaptive solution to inter-group competition.
There's no doubt the US is now split into distinct groups. The adaptiveness of a single group is not there.
Thus, I suspect Trump will continue to push a law and order theme. But, I suspect a splinter group will form, as radical as ANTIFA or BLM but with different specific tactics (targeted assassinations?). Trump's 3rd party will disavow, but these disavowals, no matter how clear, will be interpreted as messaging requiring further force. That will give them a leg up on ANTIFA. The left doesn't disavow ANTIFA, so ANTIFA is functionally limited in how far they can push things. The next evolutionary step is the one I mentioned.
US Way Behind Poland in Modern Free Speech Mediums
It looks like the US is way behind Poland in modern free speech mediums. I suspect ideological uniformity in US institutions led to this. As technocracy increases, the temptation to simply ban ones foes grows too great. Severe competition between the two sides just magnifies these temptations. Unless, of course, one side's unifying principle is libertarianism. But as we saw in the American Revolutionary war, that really didn't change the dynamics too much. You just find another term to wiggle around those ethics. Right now its hate speech. In the 50's it was communism..
And don't forget, Poland has a history of some rather progressive political principles.
Saturday, January 9, 2021
Purge Dynamics - Context Matters
The current purge dynamics, including the likely impeachment of Trump and removal of his ability to ever again take a public office, has to be seen in broader contexts.
For instance, who knows if this is real or fake. The fact that it came from Nov is worrying. The fact that no one heard about it is worrying (& a signal that it may be fake). But, purge dynamic context requires admitting that mass censorship, deplatforming (ala Parler's likely dehosting), and perception of a one-sided rule of law, make authoritarian actions especially explosive.
I think the hope is that you can break the ability of the resistance to organize. If you turn the entire country's morals against them, you can redirect lock-down energy into a Germanesque societal cleansing.
But what happens if that forces unstable people into identity fusion (like jihadi's)? And what happens when the first imolator gets lionized and the copycats start to come. Targeted assassinations, including Pelosi, news media, lock-down governors, perceived traitors like McConnel, will have to worry. That was the dynamics of the American War of Independence....
As I've said - the truth of these Italian election stuff doesn't matter for first order reactionary dynamics. But if it is true, it certainly matters for what is left of trust in the rule of law and general societal trust.
HUGE!!!! ECHO!!!! Relating to the post below. There is a link to this video testimony of an ITALIAN JUDGE about LEONARDO’S role in switching votes from President Trump to Joe Biden!!!!
-- Saturday, January 9, 2021
For context of the purge (especially if your news and associations tend to be siloed - like what is inevitable in post secondary institutions) - Tim Pool is reporting Rasmussens polls which have Trump approval (after the Capital breach) at 49%. It has gone up. Context matters. Cultural biology is like hydrodynamic instability, the more forcefully a light fluid accelerates a heavier one, the greater are the non-linearities. You get rapid bubble anti-bubble formation. In biological approaches to network theory, that tends to represent splinter group formation.
Friday, January 8, 2021
Impeachment & Civil War
I'm pretty sure Pelosi won't be able to resist impeaching Trump. Blood is in the water. Dem's have full control over social media, legacy media, all three branches of government, and McConnel and all establishment Republicans. Thus there is really no way it won't pass the Senate. Establishment Republicans want to remove any possibility of Trump 2024 or a third party split. Thus, impeachment with the disbarment from public office option is all but inevitable.
I can't believe how much that underestimates the sentiment on the ground. Half of the population have blood fever. They blame Trump for everything. I suspect he's actually de-energized a lot of revolutionary energy on the right even if he has crystallized self-organization. On the left there's no doubt he's been a tumour, but hey Mitt Romney was literally Hitler, so I think most anyone on the right would have energized left angst.
The inescapableness of impeachment due to system momentum makes US Civil War highly likely. Heck, I can imagine myself in different contexts heading down to fight. As I've suspected before, I think you'll see a targeted assassination vector into Civil War on the right. I don't give Pelosi much of a lifespan. I also think Google and Twitter offices better harden up real fast. With Covid you have a lot of suicidal people. Once the realization comes that a certain type of martyrdom comes with lots of fanfare, Pandora's box will be opened.
For a variety of reasons, there just is no way for these systems to escape some nasty level of civil conflict. It is much bigger than Trump, just as it is much bigger than Pelosi's "righteous" anger. The level of technocratic detachment from reality is too large to believe. One sided justice and loss of faith in the rule of law has ensure no system solution out of this is really possible.
Kaboom.
Monday, December 28, 2020
Woke is the new Roman Christianity
There's a lot of political upheaval down south right now. The rationalization that it's better to ignore election fraud than to risk legitimizing Trumpish bullishness will have major ramifications. There was just no way out of the US' quagmire. You either got Trump and establishment tears or you got Biden and populist tears. That the establishment would back itself should be unsurprising. And yet, many people seem genuinely shocked that the judiciary would largely ignore rule of law by choosing Robert's fairly rational stance that "whatever happens when votes are count is what stays happened". Legitimate illegality be dammed. Nothing is significant enough to overturn the ousting of a destroyer and usurper.
The energizer in all this is Wokeism.
As I've been saying for a few years, Wokeism is a new modular, guerrilla, religion. It's removal of supernaturalism, eschewment of brick-and-mortar organization, intertwinement with governance, and growing enforcement by force of law (and mob based tar-and-feathering) reflect an evolutionary step as significant as the emergence of the "World" religions.
From a Structural Demographic view (see Peter Turchin), Wokeism affords a perfect tool for elite classes to lock out aspirant elites. Realistically, it doesn't so much lock them out as control the means of their migration. Only certain vectors, like
Media -> politics
Hollywood -> politics
Activist -> politics
Establishment family -> politics
will soon be legitimized.
When you get to a high-enough level view, it's hard not to see this as an entrenchment of caste. Caste entrenchment is a hard to resist human cultural well. The evolutionary transition literature sees it (role specialization) as one of three of four key criteria for an evolutionary change. It's hard not to see its cultural change equivalent as something other than a landscape "trap".
Thus, I tend to see the whole Woke equality thing as something of a motte and bailey. It's designed to make all us commoners more equal. Heaven knows society needs something here. But it does not make society at large more equal. It, like communism and Christianity before it, make society more caste based.
The political upheaval Wokeism affords is analagous to what ancient Christianity afforded power hungry Roman elites. It is a high cost commitment display that enables a broad, competitor purge. Communism enabled much the same thing. These socialist movements all tend to resonate with progressive proximate causes. I'd wager that since the age of empires (10kya) there has been selection for governing preferences which include some level of "give-back" or "equality". The idea that leaders would, on balance want real liberty and power sharing is a-biological. What gets selected is an appearance of equality with a heart of imbalance. You need the plebes to really believe things are equal and fair. You just can't have those rules apply in any meaningful way (other than symbolically) to you.
The hypocrisy of one-sided racism and gain-power to destroy power are pretty obvious. But, they're being sold hook line and sinker to people. "This time the revolution will be different!". But what scares me, is that communist revolutions, while similar to today's moral political hysteria, missed the religious elements that enabled Christian and Islamic domination. If you read 1984, the Party needed a way, not just to cajole people into belief, but a way to really get them to believe. But this belief required support for hypocrisy. Communism was too utopian. Leaders were still theoretically required to play by the same rules as the commoners. While animals have different needs, 20th century Marxism made no allowance for difference. It just accepted that corruption was inevitable and revolution would have to be continual.
Today's Wokeism turns this around in a very pernicious way. Continual revolution between castes and within the control caste is not needed. Flipping the "patriarchy" is a feature not a bug. What could go wrong with a governing population with this mindset. It's not like they would think of deplatforming inconvenient voices - say like disbarring Sydney Powell and other people who won't shut up about things that have already been decided....
Monday, December 21, 2020
Choice - If it just saves one life...
Here's a good one for the "if it just saves one life" crowd.
Suicide rates drop after school choice laws get adopted....
Sunday, November 29, 2020
Consulting Oracles in the Old World
I've been listening to some Dan Carlin podcasts while renovating a laundry room / bathroom. One point I see repeated quite often in standard approaches to history is how illogical and superstitious it was for ancient leaders to consult oracles and temple priests concerning major state questions. I think this is just flat out wrong.
Last year I went through Wright's Evolution of God. While I can't stand his persona and attitudes as expressed on his podcasts, I really really enjoyed this book. I'm not sure why he can get the evolutionary perspective of religion so right in his books and then be so dismissive of its utility in modern contexts, or fail to see the religious aspects of wokeism or today's hyper liberalism. Oh well.
The big insight from his book was that ancient temples are best seen in terms of modern political think tanks rather than supernatural venues. They certainly represented community moral meta narratives framed supernaturally. But modern views which separate supernaturalism and religion from governance and politics, are quite frankly not the way old societies worked.
To understand this, think of the way indigenous societies, such as Plains Indians view religious narrative. At a deep level, there is no supernaturalism. It is all meta-narrative designed to teach fundamental, evolutionarily selected lessons in the most efficient way possible. The chaos/unpredictability of Napi reflects the reality of nature's randomness. I suspect, Blackfoot mythology sees this character less in supernatural terms and more in life-lesson terms.
When you apply this cultural evolution logic to ancient temples, what you get is a view that these temples curate certain political and governing perspectives / ideologies much the same way different University based think tanks do today. If you want a hawkish approach to a certain foreign policy you go to group X based on the academic school of thought. They will frame your answer nicely, pull in some post facto data to make things look good and presto. If you wanted to see how opposing views looked on your issue, just select a different group of oracles. See the end of this post (and the hole series) for some more discussion.
The one thing missing with today's political think tanks is their tight connection to public opinion. Modern think tanks can serve up opinion surveys, but until the rise of the moral activist press, they really have never embodied a group of committed followers in the same way ancient religious cults did. Now, however, I would suspect "consulting BLM or other wokeish cults" would be very much the same.
Imagine Biden going to BLM to see how supporting Chineses interests in Ethiopia would go over? Are my drone attacks going to be seen as anti-black? You might get an answer like, no, as long as you phrase it this way, and you pay the right sort of price to keep us, the media, and the folks we influence on your side.
This is VERY much like ancient oracles. The main difference is that ancient oracles / temple groups, probably leveraged the poetry of old textual styles more. Nowdays our speech is very prole. We expect clarity. But imagine if speech from educated folk was expected to be Biblical (or Shakespearan). Matter of fact speech would be too vulgar. Why? In these cases it would be too blunt and afford the regal asker not enough freedom of movement. In a kingly world, that is bad. Piss off the king, and your cult is in danger. Get too many things wrong and you become a Lincoln Project grifter. The cultural evolution market selects for a certain level of ambiguity. Politically, people are coming to the oracle for this. The king needs to show his people that they sought some outside advice. That outside advice was in the scope of the king's plans. The king took some of that advice to heart and mitigated risk accordingly. The people are now more satisfied that a protected group, who has a fair bit of range to speak to real risks, backs you. This oracle group also pushes some political wheels and some populist wheels. It gives a nice "talking point" narrative for public consumption. This is often framed in meta-narrative mythic form. But, usually the depth of mythic form depends upon the depth of the existential threat facing everyone as a whole.
So, Dan Carlin and others, don't discount the wisdom in old leaders like Leonidas going to the oracle of Delphi before the battle with the Persians. There were probably real political, real populist, and real strategic reasons to do so. Did this consultant see the populace having your back through this? As the 2020 US election shows, media narrative and media control do matter. Knowing just the right narrative to sell can be crucial. Just think of how Tech Bro's multi-year prep for hate-speech and misinformation checks played out. Who's back would other countries have? That insight is what you pay an oracle for. In the ancient world, the distribution of temples across multiple states gave them significant insight into what was happening on the ground and and elite levels of state.
Friday, November 20, 2020
Lockdown Consequentialism
Like many places, Toronto is going into a Covid lockdown. While not as dramatic as the Australian Reicht moves, I thought I'd do a simple analysis.
Sounds like they've had 8 Covid deaths today. Let's assume it would get a factor of 10 worse without the lockdown. That would be 80 deaths a day.
Let's assume a Toronto level lock-down affects only 2 hours of people's day M-S. You can't go to a movie. You can't hang out with friends. It's a net quality of life bummer of 2 hours a day for your 29h free time week (M-F = 3h, S-S=12h). For people like me, the psychological burden of authoritarianism is MUCH higher. But, this seems reasonable. Lots of people just watch TV. And many people will just ignore dumb rules (hence Australian authoritarianism).
So with 6 million people in Toronto locked up for a stratified problem, we get 12 million people hours (1.2 x 10^7 )of lock up each day. A lifespan of 80 years is about 700,000 hours. 80 deaths mean about 6 x 10^7 equivalent hours of life. That's about a fair trade off.
But, we have to assume that people dying aren't losing a life from age 0. Kids rarely die from Covid (99.997% survivability in 0-19). So I made up a simple spreadsheet based on Canada's demographics and CDC relative death risks by age group and found the total number of early-death-hours based upon an expected lifespan of 80 years. For 80 deaths I get 1.6 million early-death-hours.
Thus, the covid lock-down will save 1.6 million early-death-hours each day at a cost of 12 million hours of meaningful lock up. So your lock up time to loss of time ratio needs to be about 10:1 to break even. That means you would rather lose 1 hour of your life if you got 10 hours of meaningful freedom.
Lock-downs are close to a washout. They don't really save any more life-time than they cost. All you get out of them is a sense that you're doing something at the cost of absolute destruction of
- the economy,
- people's enjoyment of life,
- trust in government,
- and decrease in social support net (due to deficit costs).
What probably happens is we have to work more to pay for our lockdowns (due to increase tax rates). Therefore the lock down hours of life saved are probably more than made up for by the loss of life-freedom-hours and tax-workload-hours.
I'll take Liberty and a Stratified response please.....

