Thursday, November 5, 2020

Error

 Well it looks like I blew the election prediction. I figured Trump would sneak by in PA, WI and maybe MI for a 290 - 300 take.  Now it looks like even GA may flip blue.


Both sides' fall-back states are getting the late votes they need that just cause them to eek by. It's a game of he who counts last gets to count just right.  In this PA is king, and mail-in voting from big urbans is your savior.  See the Barnes video (he seems well used to the chicanery played in Bush-Gore Florida).


The real issue is obviously, should late votes count (rule of law) or does every vote matter. The latter matches the Black Lives Matter ethos so perfectly, I suspect it reflects the major moral fault line facing the US (and other countries).

Do you go so progressive that everything matters that no one can be left out or not made to achieve equal outcomes? Or, do you stay hard nosed, keeping tight arbitrary norms, which inevitably exclude things in "racialized" ways.


THE BIOLOGY 
As I've said before, globalization, specifically pan-nationalism, reflects one deep seated biological tendency now being probed by groups. It is operationalized by an out-group focussed, no-borders societal approach. But his increases the likelyhood of severe gaming (freeloading). If norms can't keep up with things, the adaptiveness of your group implodes.

That, is what people fear about the US right now. In order to win an election, the blue side opened things up so much, so quickly, in such a norm breaking way, it was going to be near impossible for faith in rule of law to stay. The red side's fight against systemic bias in the system is similarly burning up social cohesion capital.

So while I think Hillary certainly used her dirty political machine to nail Trump, and while I think corrupt Biden decided to play in the gutter to hit Trump and save his son (& political elites) from jail, I think it wouldn't matter who won or who didn't. The US is now functionally ungovernable, and the structural forces that led it to be that way are increasing and really can't be tamped down.


CONCLUSION
So while I would have preferred a purge of the deep state, more legs to the current Israeli peace movement, and a removal of woke religion from public institutions, it seems like the deep-state's supporting edifices have finally proved too much for Trump.  The odds were never in his favour. Covid and the leverage it gave for voting norm shifts proved too much for non-elite populism to overcome. Big tech thumbs were just enough to edge it out. Trump's achille's heel was always getting too many enemies. But it was also his strategic strength. It caused everyone to fire all their guns. Sometimes the superposition proves just too much.

Wednesday, November 4, 2020

Weekend Violence

 Other than a house contested election, this looks to be about the worst scenario possible for election violence.


I got surprised that Biden took Arizona so easily. Some republicans still think mail-in and absentee ballots may make that a pre-mature call, but I doubt it.


That leaves Pennsylvania as the key to the whole election. They allow late voting and don't require signature matching.  That's a rife combo for fraud.  In addition, Pittsburg is a known hotspot for election shenanigans. 


That leaves both camps ready to come out this weekend at the same time in their "shows of commitment". That spells disaster!  I doubt things will be sorted out by then. But the legal theatrics will have peaked. That means my model for civil unrest (R celebrations peaking Tuesday and Wed, D protests peaking on the weekend) is wrong.  You'll get competing demonstrations and violence will ensue.


Add to this, the Supreme court's decision under Roberts to steer away from uniform voter decisions to favour state autonomy via some convoluted reasoning between which non-legislative rule changes are and aren't allowed under emergency Covid measures, and you're going to end up with a Supreme Court deciding the whole election via its call on Pennsylvania.


Decisions like that which the populace sees are fairly arbitrary and politicized do not bode well for civil stability.


It is going to get nasty as duelling protests gradually ramp up. The rate at which violence emerges all depends on how much control Democratic grass root activists have over BLM and Antifa. I think the dragon is out of the box on this one.

Tuesday, November 3, 2020

Why are Pollsters Wrong?

Why pollsters this year were as wrong as last year is going to be source of endless punditry. This will be doubly true over the next few weeks as news networks struggle to avoid uncomfortable riot coverage.


Some people push a DNC-media collusion narrative with respect to systemic polling bias. I just don't buy that. While I'm sure some "news" agencies purposefully push misleading polls in order to grab attention or sell a narrative, I really doubt the aggregate of polling institutions do this.


Rather, it seems likely pollster's just haven't kept up with the demographic shifts that track the moral changes now occurring in political-group identity.  An example in simpler terms may be apt. The left's intersectionalism now means they're the party of "racists" (classical racists at least). See California prop #16.  This has shifted a lot of classical liberals over into the Trump-if-I-must camp. Similarly law and order has shifted a lot of inner city minorities into non-traditional political camps. And, the very wealthy have shifted from Republican to Democrats. Never Trump neo-con's are the obvious example.


But, this just begs the deeper question - why haven't pollsters recognized, what are too many, very obvious social shifts? It's like the woke left that can't even conceptualize how they're the new racists and how the dynamics of BLM supremacy mirrors KKK supremacy. It's the revolutionists blind-side. After most any revolution, the revolutionists become basically indistinguishable from those they overthrew.  Why?


This feels like a General Systems complexity question (see Bathalamy's research from the 1930's - 1960's).


My suspicion is that pollsters just can't control for the levels of tribal group migration/realignment we're now seeing. More importantly, they aren't trying to figure it out.  Because of this they're functionally blind with respect to the changes that actually matter for the levels of precision they're after.


Nate Silver's tunnel vision epitomizes this. They just don't feel how far the world has shifted. And, I would guess there is a sizeable systemic bias in the friends networks. They are just too isolated amongst liberal elite circles to really sense the magnitude of what is happening in the deplorable and red-pill castes.

Sunday, November 1, 2020

Nov 3 week riots: Predictions

Early polling suggests a Trump win. Campaign actions hint at an electoral blowout (think - Minnesota is in play!).




So how will the Left's commitment to protest intersect with the Right's growing jubilance and rally energy?





Social media and legacy media are certain to tamp down any proclamations of victory. But, I suspect, electorally, things will be pretty clear. While many swing states will have a razor thin margin that mail in votes and post dated fraud could flip, I suspect Trumpers are going to ignore all priestly advice and are going to go CRAZY in the street.

I don't think one can underestimate the enthusiasm that gets generated when a persecuted group overcomes all odds and all institutional pressure against them and wins. Here are the adaptive energizers:

  • lots of public physical assaults against Trump voters
  • Trump yard sign vandalism
  • obvious social media throttling and censorship against Trumpists (& centrists)
  • the Biden corruption vs Russia hoax journalism differentials
  • the McCarthyist blackballing and deplatforming of mainstream conservatism
  • the violent ANTIFA - BLM "protests" & their "non-violent" property destruction
  • the rise of racial supremacy (KKK level progressive intersectionalism)
  • the meta-narrative-breaking rise of minority-based Trump groups (blacks for Trump, gays for Trump)
  • etc

So, I think Trumpists will head out Tues and Wed for YUGE celebrations. If Trump rallies are drawing 50k+ then the celebrations are going to be huge. People locked down by Corona are going to want to get together. The Trump energy is very much based on "positive" energy as opposed to ANTIFA styled "tear it down" energy. There are going to be street parties galore, especially in locked-down blue states. It will be a big FU to ppl like Whitmore.

The suburban mom group that ANTIFA-BLM relies on for coverage will likely hold off until the election is called by official channels. I don't think the masses will have the energy necessary for early protests. They will be despondent because of the fake poll lies. And, social media has been wise enough to try and forestall confrontation by setting structural throttles for conclusive election declarations. Biden karens seem highly likely to follow the advice of their moral priests and secular shamans.

That means their protest energy should peak closer to the weekend. The media will have time to properly spin "the steal". And social media should have had time to rip out broker nodes on conservative social networks.

That leaves Proud Boy types and Antifa types squaring off on the weekend, with suburban moms flushing out Antifa numbers. That spells bad news for the more violent Trumpers. They are likely to get really hurt. Progressives angst is going to be huge. And, this group of Trump aligned nationalists have shown they won't back down and suffer public space to be fully controlled by those who refuse to acknowledge rule-of-law (and its associated social contact) expectations.




But, maybe, Trump enthusiasm will continue into the weekend. I doubt it. I suspect they think "rule of law has spoken", and will feel no need to rub victory in.

That leaves defence of public space as the only likely reactionary dynamic. I suspect many will give law & order a chance here. I suspect they expect Trump to pull in the national guard and "take the gloves off". That's kind of stupid since most of that power is at the state level. But, nobody said ppl are rational....

... that leaves a worse reactionary backlash as all but inevitable as violent weekend rioting fails to get quelled. It gets even worse as mainstream media figures express solidarity with "intensely peaceful protests".

But I don't think you'll see many rightwing militias coming out to do police's jobs for them. I suspect you'll see a growing COLD anger. You'll certainly have a number of proud boy groups getting nasty. But, conservatives tend to be slow to anger. Hence you'll see growing background energization on the right until it suddenly breaks in two to four years.  

That's why I continue to think an assassination based entry into civil war by rightwing extremists is the most likely vector for civil war. The exception I've always predicted is if in 2024 a reactionary wokeist gets into power. Then the right will go down the road of unbridled mob violence as 2nd A rights get trampled and UK styled authoritarianism gets enacted..."for people's own safety".

Saturday, October 31, 2020

Cold Anger

 A couple of days ago I noticed an article on conservative's "cold anger". I think it captures things almost perfectly.


I've always said Canada tends to have a populace that is very slow to anger. You let people be who they are. But, there's a tipping point where the country just goes into a rage. It's a very Scandanavian thing. But it's also a very Native thing.


Why? Because it is extremely adaptive. Islamic terrorists show one angle as to why it is adaptive. It reflects a highly cohered group. Highly cohered groups are almost always adaptive. But, they can get outcompeted by larger groups. So what you need is an open group that has norms or tests to detect likely freeloaders and then the ability to rapidly phase change into a suicidal mob. But who's target of suicidal angst is something that is winnable.


That's where jihadist Islam fails. It has optimized itself for the long game. By doing so it is risking existential annihilation by the western militaries. But the larger group seems to have bet, by way of its outlier population (extremists), that it is sufficiently seeded across the world to survive. I would wager, a part of these fused identities has wagered that Ottoman or German level genocides are unlikley. There are no signs that radicalism is going to be stopped. If there were signs, any suicidal nut would be looking to see if their terrorism would cause the death of their extended family and their village. This doesn't happen (outside of the Taliban doing it). So, its pretty clear that existential risks are minimal. This makes long-game calculus a much better pay off than it normally ever is in evolutionary games.


CONSERVATIVE COLD ANGER


As the articles mention, conservatives feel numerous systemic pressures building against them. Twitter, facebook, and google censor them like nothing. And, then tell lawmakers to their face that it is not intentional, it is just enforcement of pro-social norm policy.


Supression of conservatives in the public space was huge up until a month or two ago. BLM and Antifa goons had claimed ownership of public gatherings. Any pro non-progressive group was purposefully excluded from space by the charge of "we can't let these Nazi's organize". Except that Nazi and white supremacist was now applied to anyone right of AOC. Black people had their racial identity erased. The most vile racist language now comes from BLM Antifa goons. But it is never mentioned in any news feed. It's just not the right narrative. And right wing media tends not to obsess over speech the way the left does (maybe to their demise, but doing so would also likely erode their founding moral cohesive ethos - classical liberalism).


So, as I look around the nets, interact with youth, union leaders, teachers, health professionals, I see a growing sense of people having their heads down in the sand, holding back the expression of their angst until after the November election. You read between the lines that they still expect rule of law to provide a barrier against chaos, extra-legal rule, and mob violence which is politically condoned. Plus, should they do anything overt, the whole system will crash down on them and use it to further de-legitimize them. The difference in coverage between Charlottesville and the 120 days + of Antifa rioting and violence is stark.


But, once the election ends, I think people's tolerance will be used up. The left will be going crazy with a Trump win. Trump will push all their buttons as he puts people like Flynn in charge of the DNI and starts to think about replacing Barr with Giulianni due to Barr's inability and unwillingness to institute reform.


But as those "resist" riots play out. The cold anger of the right is going to go hot. Trump rallies are how people are testing the waters of expression. The job firings and digital tar-and-featherings, while as strong as ever, aren't cowering people (other than academics). Project veritas is going crazy with the number of whistleblowers coming their way who are knowingly giving up their livelihoods.


A cold anger has been created. It is not the hot suicidal range of the identity fused jihadist. Rather it is the cold calculation of a soldier storming a beach.  You know the odds aren't good. But, the false hysteria that its death to step out is gone. The adaptive signals of the group are sufficient to support a rational decision to go into the meat grinder. Politically, I think conservatives know how the Nov riots are going to go. It is going to be ugly. But I think they have decided to engage.


That leaves only one question - how violent will the BLM Antifa groups be towards the rural folk and subarbanites who simply sit down on the ground while the Black Clad thugs surround and threaten them.  What percentage of the Cold Angered will head down the Proud Boys path of retributional violence? What percentage will start to become pro-active (assassins)?


I'm willing to wager, it will be quite a bit. 


Why?


Because adaptively, it will need to be a sufficient quantity of people doing sufficient actions to make the other side realize that the whole country could go to pot. Until CNN is truly scared enough to feel a mob, with nor restraints, is headed their way looking for a scalp, the fire will continue to get more logs thrown on it. And, during that process, a growing number of Cold Angered rationalists will turn Jihadi. Then it's just a numbers game about the civil war model the States enters into.

Thursday, October 29, 2020

Covid Crazy

 I just did a rough crunch of the numbers for Canada based upon the CDC's fatality rates (by the way who makes a rookie mistake like listing the Infection fatality rate as a decimal, but labelling it as a percent!!!)



and StatCanada's population by age numbers. And while the parsing doesn't exactly line up, I get a rough value of about 53k dead under 70'ers, and 300k-400k dead 70 pluser's.

I just don't know how you justify any of the extreme measures we're now doing without pushing for age stratified responses.  It is just unfathomable how politicians are keeping state of emergencies on for this.

Take precautions, but this is a stratified problem....

Here are a couple of reasonable videos on the issue (not everything is getting banned - just heavily throttled




Friday, October 9, 2020

If it just saves one life ...

Utilitarianim's and consequentialism's main idea is that outcomes determine something's normative properties. Is a Covid lockdown good? It depends upon how outcomes aggregate. Time scales are always an issue. You also have to determine how to handle Black Swan events (improbable events that might not occur when the same scenario is repeated, even if all conditions remain the same). Fitness in biology is very concerned about similar issues. Has the covid lockdown been more of a net positive or net negative? 

Obviously one can't really judge. But as per Steven Crowder's recent lockdown protest and demand for open info suggests, people are at the point where messages of "take care if you have cold symptoms" have been recieved as much as they can, and people are legitimately demanding open information about lock down efficacy vs costs. Facebook and twitter info bans do nothing to further this conversation. Neither does legacy media's refusal to do any sort of investigative journalism on the real issues. That leads to polarization.



ALBERTA 

Here's some research me and my wife did. We were on opposite sides of lockdowns and masks in the Spring (with me being much more cautious than she was as a nurse). Lately we've switched positions and remain on opposite sides (with her now being in favour of mask mandates and its associated authoritarianisms). If it just saves one life, and the personal costs are low....

Alberta's Covid deaths are as of Oct 8 are about 283.  The Heritage Foundation shows that in the US, the percentage of deaths in the under 55 age group are about 8% of the total deaths. This means Alberta should expect to have about 23 deaths under 55 due to Covid. Most of those likley have co-morbities to them.

How does this compare to increases caused by Covid lock down dynamics occurring from suicide?

Alberta has about 550 suicides per year. Coroner information from the US suggests an increase in suicide rates of about 30% this year.  Yakima Washington says their rate is now about 30% higher that it was pre-covid.  Other hard stats aren't "hard", so we'll use a 20% figure as a "safe bet".  The distribution of suicides by under 55's is about 40%-50%. (I used absolute suicide rates and didn't adjust by % of population). 

That means we would normally expect on the order of 240-250 suicides by under 55's in Alberta. But with the 20% or so increase due to Covid, we now have an additional 50 or so.

THAT IS twice the deaths caused by the lockdown that have occurred due to Covid.

This doesn't mean a lockdown hasn't saved more lives. It certainly may have. But it does suggest one really needs to question whether the social effects of the lockdown exceed its severity. 

This doesn't account for the fairly large number of deaths that are occurring due to breaks in medical service. I know my mom had a close-enough call due to an infection that normally wouldn't have occurred without a lock down.


CONCLUSION
Failure to account for secondary deaths due to the lockdown is immoral.  This includes failure to account for the absolute devastation done to social contracts, civil life, and debt levels which down the road will certainly curtail social net spending.

If it just saves one life rhetoric is not a moral position with respect to covid lock downs. It may be that lock downs save many lives. But they also cost many lives. The best solution would seem to be one that allows freedom of choice and institutes safety measure for vulnerable populations.

Clearly the West is not doing that. I hate to say it, but I suspect Sweden provides a good case study. Victoria province in Australia, the UK, California, Minnesota and New York provide good case studies on the other side. Authoritarianism has very real consequences. It is almost always justified by "if it just saves one life" logic. Then you just ramp up to the next level of "small things need to just save one more life".

See any of JP's Awaken comedies for satire on the issue.




Sunday, September 6, 2020

Ed: Pluralism or Religion

Ed is starting its deep dive into its role as a pluralistic coherer or religious indoctrinator. Religious indoctrination seems to be its historical role (up until the end of the enlightenment era). There's normally a pacing and leading which happens between religion and governance (see Norenzayan's Big Gods). For a while governance adopts the lessons learned by religion, but does so in a more pluralistic way that enables group size increase or other adaptive group traits. For a while religion leads. Right now Ed is ostensibly determining (along with society) whether -everyone is equal under the law, or -some people are more equal than others (for the sake of equality of outcomes). Applied Critical Theory certainly takes the latter, Orwellian approach. Recently it seems like fricition within Alberta's Teachers Association is just starting to reflect this dichotomoy. The Orange bubble urban areas are heading one way, while rural venues are heading the other. There are structural reasons why urban centers gain ideological dominance within large institutions. This seems to be a historical "law". But this tendency isn't neutral, or "progressive". It simply reflects the cultural evolution cycles Peter Turchin describes in his Secular Cycles work and Cliodynamics. It leads to periodic revolutions, purges, and societal collapses. Fighting these cult like Trosky tendencies is not easy. By the time these behaviours become non-ignorable, instituitional technocracies and structures are largely monopolized by ideological conformity. Self selective processes gradually tip the balance toward homogeneity, and it is very rare that enough counter-balancing momemtum can be generated to bring things back into balance before over-reach leads to collapse. We'll have to see where things end up in the West. My guess is that much of US education is in serious trouble. Canada's pluralistic nature (and lower population) may give it enough breathing room to survive. But, here in Alberta at least, there are going to be some nasty fireworks as the Urban progressive minority start going head to head with the sleepy conservative base.

Friday, September 4, 2020

A Peaceful Protest?

 More peaceful protests continue. Not all involve mobs of people </irony>