Friday, November 13, 2020

Overboard? People's bans on politicians

 A decent number of people are in favour of lockdowns. As I've mentioned before, there is definitely a small bias in human nature that makes moves toward castes and caste based authoritarianism more adaptive than not. It's the evolutionary selection arrow for larger polities.


Democracy curtails this trend in interesting ways. It puts the majority of the people in charge of leadership decisions.  In most cases this still results in a creep toward European style state paternalism. But, in the US, it resulted in a resistance to big state power.


Covid emergency powers (which never seem to be going away) supplant constitutional rights for individual liberty. If you want to lock someone down because they are sick - fine. But if you want to pre-emptively lock them down because you're looking at things at a population level, not individual level, then not-fine.


So I look at this tiny signal with a bit more interest than normal.



We know that facebook-twitter-google ban people for their identity and political/social views. We know gofund-me and monitary service providers ban people for wrongthink too (at least wrongthinkg that energizes a mob based upon journalistic threats like "please comment on your support for X's white supremacy views). We know that BLM and political machines try to ban people for wrongthink.  That's why it's interesting to see the populace thinking about doing the same thing.


Remember, during the American revolution, loyalists and patriots were banned from commerce and public social venues based upon their identity.  I suspect this is a fairly good way for the populace to let politicians know when they've crossed a line.

But, It will of course result in the hardening of political-identity groups. That seems to be the natural trajectory of things now. Something as historically simple as a minor plague may reveal more about tribalization and weak empire splits than we could have ever imagined.

Thursday, November 12, 2020

Minimal Counter-Intuitiveness & Voter "fraud" Debate

 I was just going through one of the Cultural Evolution Society's podcasts on Cognitive Biases in Folklore.



They don't raise many points you wouldn't already have heard from Scott Atran's In God We Trust. But, they do mention that it is stories as a whole and not elements within a story upon which cultural selection for minimal counter-intuitiveness operates.

That has some implications for the current voter fraud debate.

Right now we're getting tonnes of "just so" voter fraud and voting extra-legality (back dated time stamps, observer exclusion, 100% Biden vote batches, programmed hardware bias, etc.).  Each one is a bit hard to believe, but is certainly plausible. But, as a whole, people around me tend to think the sum of all of it is definitely conspiracy theory land.

The narrative as a whole has too many slightly counter-intuitive ideas.

If the cultural evolution theory is right, what should happen is that the narrative should change so that only a few slightly counter-intuitive ideas are present.  Thus the narrative should predictably evolve into something like "systemic voting bias which slightly favours Biden".  This seems to be happening.

But, what is also interesting, is that along this way, you should have voters thinking either:

- All this is just too coincidental to be true. Trump is grasping at straws to stay in power.  This could occur due to post hoc rationalization (I hate Trump, or I don't want to disbelieve that all media are fairly fake). Or it could occur due to a rational assessment of the probability of so many "just so" stories all being true.  This reflects analysis at the elemental level.

-All this is just too coincidental to be true. Biden must really have pulled some strings to play as unfair as he thought Trump would. After all, what could people who believe Trump's literally Hitler justify as fair. This could occur due post hoc bias. It could also occur due to rational assessment of the evidence (each actor has a slight probability to do something within their control to slightly influence results, none of which is extra-ordinarily unusual. Or, the big guy & Hillary said "unleash the hounds" within their political machines). This reflects selection at the story level.

This leaves one with two competing stories. Trump is an aspiring dictator. Biden reflects or enabled systemic extra-legality. Both are slightly counter-intuitive to swing people. What I expect we should see for detail is that the elements told in each retelling then get switched based on the audience one talks to. After all, believers within one camp wouldn't find either of these narratives hard to believe. For the story to be meme-orable, you'd need a better level of counter-intuitiveness.

In religion this is "putting your pearl's before swine" logic. It reflects the ideas in the side-bar on lynch-pin signalling.

Monday, November 9, 2020

2+2=5

The other month James Lindsay had a twitter feud with the 2+2=5 group. For those not up on that discourse, it's basically Critical Theory saying everything is relative. That tool is now being applied in the harder sciences. Part of that is to get easy papers published (academia always needs a new kick for job progression). 


Part of the thinking is accurate. Not all operators or things are always understood the same way. That's why assumptions are always baked into discourse. One argument is that things like addition operators and numbers are well defined. Therefore, if you're using slightly different logic, it's on you to explain your assumptions, not upon others to infer them. This is what separates white supremacy from Critical Theory.


But, the power dynamic boils down to being able to say 2+2=5 and being free from critique. It's what 1984 discussed with respect to the ultimate goals of newspeak - being able to eliminate any ties language has to objectivity. The narrative matters more than objectivity. Why? We've already got enough objectivity.


It's hard not to see the media's reaction to the Biden laptop (there is no evidence it gives) or the censorship of election issues in the same light.  For instance, twitter is now banning Benford Law links (the standard? statistical analysis used to look for fraud, including voter fraud). Or, perhaps more accurately, they're banning specific links which tie Benford's law to voter fraud and then specifically cite the objective data on swing state votes.


It's not just that saying "2+2=4" is getting you banned off twitter, youtube or facebook.  It's that discussion must say 2+2=5 and saying 2+2=4 is offensive, divisive and aligns you with white supremacy.


Is that just the natural trap that cultish utopian movements fall into? "Say the name of God". Just recognize our power/legitimacy (in an Orwellian way).  It seems like once you can't say objective facts because they convey the wrong meta-narrative balance, you're in trouble. Once too many people start believing 2+2=4, then the overlords will say, then we have a problem. They're trying to curate the right level of detachment from reality. And, that's scary.




Sunday, November 8, 2020

War Game: Is the Chicanery going as planned?

Remember the election war game white paper from this summer that most people dismissed as conspiracy theory thinking? (see one report). Is it going as planned?


I think so.


If I remember, the talking points around its analysis suggested the key for things for the Dems was to gain narrative control early. This would pressure state legislatures not to disrupt things. Media control was used to ensure Trump couldn't declare early victory. Slow counting was key to enable this. Then media control would declare Biden victory.  One weak point was how to solidify this without seeming duplicitous. Getting foreign leaders to congratulate early seems to be a very smart innovation since the white paper came out.


The war game's likely scenario was that some electors would not be able to validate the election. That would leave things up to the house. 

I suspect that's where we'll wind up. 


I think that is the best and fairest case anyway. Republicans might not like it. But it seems the most honest. Then the Trumpist move is to stoke Pelosi's ego so it happens. Then, from the Republican side, Biden is castigated. 


As far as the Supreme court goes. If things get to them with respect to uncertified electors, they may decide they need to nip election chicanery in the bud. The easiest way to do that is to enable uncertified electors, trusting the House not to upset the Dem's wise move of getting things called early. Plus, this protects Deep State institutions and corruptions from Trump's laptop enabled criminal probe.


The main chip Trump has to play here is the special prosecutor chip. If this scenario buys Trump off from burning down "corrupt" elite actors & institutions with a vindictive special prosecutor, Trump MIGHT go for it. He goes down as less of a loser, at the cost of unfulfilled revenge.


I think that deal would work for him. He's taking the bet that state apparati will resist any criminal investigation so much it probably won't happen. The media will play cover for that. Therefore the safe bet is to avoid tearing the country down more, and get it out in the open that "extra-legal" means were used. This then forces government strucutres to come out and decide how to enfrancise voters via mail-in or equivalent means while figuring out how to keep just the right number of extra late counted votes from going to your side.


Here's the logic that keeps things from an early shutdown - provided of course the war game plan to demoralize Trump does not succeed. If I remember, that seemed to be a key point mentioned in the war game play.




link for this excellent twitter thread statistical analysis











Saturday, November 7, 2020

Rabbit Hole

 Looks like I'm heading down the rabbit hole in election conspiracies.  I stumbled on the Penssylvania GOP site and it was better than rando social media (which is infinitely better than any big media). Then I went to Barne's Law, as his experience (doing?) and litigating fraud, including in Gore Florida. That brought me to some technical analysis, which being a mathematician I enjoyed.


That's when I got mad.  P-values of 10^-147       yes -147      yes!!!!!


Here are some threads



And to think social media will throttle all this to the nth degree - because "narrative" & "illegitimate use" by conspiracy theorist nuts.

Optics

 Most election fraud stories can be explained non-conspiratorially. The issue seems to be the perfect storm of:

  • Tech giant censorship
  • Biden has his son's jailtime riding on this
  • Biden has his legacy riding on this
  • Hillary will do anything for revenge (and to avoid Clinton foundation investigation)
  • The media, via the Hunter laptop, has shown they will deny the sun is yellow to avoid giving anything to Trump
  • The media and many elites are now a de-facto quasi-religion who don't want their sacred utopian ideals repudiated
  • Media has no credibility
  • Mail in voting obviously enables electioneering (all votes matter rationalization or Ilhan Omar styled pay-outs)
  • One opponent is literally considered Hitler
  • People are willing to riot, burn and beat to not give space to Trumpists
  • China, Iran, and many other world powers obviously prefer Biden to Trump
  • Trump is gunning to expose Obama and lots of power players
  • The intelligence agencies are about to get exposed via Flynn's return to head of the NSA of DNI
  • Guilianni was likely going to replace Barr to "get some blood" and pull a RICO on Antifa-BLM and whichever politicians were colluding them to RICO standards.
The major problem though, is, while each of these are conspiracy theory type stuff, the throttling of info means none of it can be discussed rationally.

The logic is that enabling rational discussion last election is what enabled Trump to play the dynamics of populism. The establishment vowed that should never happen again.  But what that means is channels like this one, with a few POTENTIALLY disturbing issues, are siloed and prevent a nexus of verification from occuring.

That's bad. It also makes for back reactionary dynamics.  Watch most any historical movie about tribal groups fighting off an imperial power. It's always the prevention of expression or culture that is the rallying cry. Stories rely on that for a reason....

So look at this to see what's throttled. Some of it is obviously conspiratorial low percentage issues. But, so was Epstein Island and Weinstein, and Flynn frame job, and.....     That's the dynamics at play. 

https://twitter.com/PhillyGOP

My now "Restricted" blog

 Looks like this blog is now in a restricted mode on Parler. It wasn't yesterday. 

https://parler.com/profile/Cgoble72

Not sure why. I checked various google blacklist tools to see if academic discussion about election dynamics from an evolutionary perspective are now banned (by the a very open social media site). Nothing.


I still come up in google search terms. So this is very interesting... Not sure what I did to anger the algorithms.


(And yes, I did test posting links to other blogger blogs)

The Ethos of Inclusion: Forces its Formalization via Lawfare?

The sanest way to think of Trump's lawfare w voter "fraud" is to think of it as forcing out some uniform rules for future elections. 


  • When does voting start and end?  The moment you write your ballot or the moment it is recieved? Or anytime up until the hegemony gets what it wants because "all votes matter"
  • What type of ID do we really want?  None? All persona's are legal? Exclusionary ID like photo ID like most Western countries?
  • How do you balance security against "every vote matters" inclusion?
  • And most importantly, what role is voter harvesting going to play? And how does it get safeguarded?


The last point is the most salient, but hardest to confront through lawfare.  One side will deny its existence. But as Blogojevich's recent Fox interview, and Ilhan Omar's project Veritas expose with the Somali community - it is alive and well and certainly played a pivotal role in Trump's loss (though apparently hard to find on youtube even with direct search terms...)

But just making it illegal isn't going to change much. It is a default modus operandi.  Whoever doesn't play with it won't survive for long.  This reality has been hammered home to the politically naive and inexperienced Trump.

Results support the Democratic narrative that there are huge numbers of voters for whom the old process doesn't enfrancise.  How do you accommodate their political interests without guaranteeing more "extra legal stuff" that, for many, is now part of the ethos of inclusion?


 

Friday, November 6, 2020

Evolutionary Transitions & Political Trajectory Wells




"All votes matter" vs "Conservative rule of law"

This post could have been called: Why we're seeing the "All votes matter" ethoses pushing ballot counting one way while "Conservative rule of law" is pushing it another. 

Written another way, it comes out as
  • "doing the right thing by people" by way of  "if it just saves one life" heart-string-tugs / villainization
  • save the system by giving up what seems compassionate for the moment, but which kills boundary maintenance & system trust (by way exploitive manipulation guard erosion). 


In practice, the rhetoric of white supremacist (intersectional logic) emerges as essential for understanding what is happening.  See James Lyndsay's twitter or New Discourses to see why.  



THE HEARTLESS TRAP
The "all votes matter" logic is impossibly hard to refute: at least within large populations where individuals are largely insulated from the direct effects of their aggregated individual decisions. For instance "all votes matter logic", where you always have to stretch to accommodate just one more thing/item/person, is not a general feature of aboriginal populations. These groups have great intra-support networks. And individuals within them go to great extents to avoid greed & grift. But, if you break norms there is absolutely no slack given. The tribe does no sacrifice itself for individuals who violate (logical or irrational) survival norms. They are EXTREMELY conservative.



THE INESCAPABLE PROGRESSIVE VECTOR
The rhetorical position of "all lives matter", represented by ballot counting norm changes & open border logic, is an inescapable vector in human groups.

This means, in the long run, you really can never beat the State (as Trump has found out). The State will always tend to grift and enlargement. This follows Evolutionary Transition literature. 

According to this literature, systems are selected for:
  1. dependency increases (eg big gov, social state, we riot if you don't support us)
  2. role specialization (eg elite classes, sacred identities)
  3. coordination (eg media, state collusion)
  4. conflict minimization (eg the application of law which "solves" noisy voices, authoritarianism, selective prosecution, special rules for key organs)
To expect these tendencies not to be expressed in government means fighting the inescapable current of human evolution. That states like revolutionary France, revolutionary US, etc. have been able to do this for a time is rare. 

1800's European critiques of the survivability of Jeffersonian democracy are apt. The US was always a rare blip.